A long-time associate of Hyman Roth, he was present at the meeting for Hyman Roth's birthday along with Dominic, Michael, Fredo, Aldo, Rico Granados, Samuele Mangano and Alejandro Almeida. Ciccoricco was sent to infiltrate the Granados family in 1959 after relations between Roth and Granados reached breaking point. He was ultimately discovered whilst investigating their smuggling rackets and held hostage.
Ciccoricco was about to be executed by Granados' men when he was rescued by Dominic Corleone, newly arrived from New York. His fate after Hyman Roths execution is unknown, he presumably went into hiding or was arrested by the authorites for the crimes he did.